· Back to Blog

California’s SB 54 Must Deliver Real Recycling and Less Packaging Waste

California’s landmark packaging law, SB 54, has the potential to transform how packaging is designed, managed, and recycled. But getting the details right will be critical to ensuring the law delivers on its promise to reduce waste, expand reuse, and strengthen recycling systems.

AMBR submitted comments to the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) on Circular Action Alliance’s (CAA) proposed Program Plan for implementing SB 54.

Drawing on our members’ decades of experience collecting, sorting, and processing recyclable materials, we identified several areas where the Plan needs significant improvements.

Our key concerns include:

  • Protecting existing recycling systems. The Plan relies too heavily on curbside collection of plastic film and flexible packaging, which can contaminate paper recycling streams, increase costs, and undermine existing recycling markets. Collection strategies must be backed by demonstrated recycling outcomes and responsible end markets.
  • Making producers pay the true cost of their packaging. Proposed fees for difficult-to-recycle packaging appear too low and could encourage producers to switch to cheaper, less recyclable materials. Fees should reflect actual costs and create meaningful incentives for waste prevention, reuse, and better packaging design.
  • Ensuring recycling claims reflect reality. Materials should only count as recycled when there is verifiable evidence they become usable recycled feedstock. We are calling for stronger end-market standards, minimum recycling yields, and transparent tracking of physical material flows. Fuel production, energy recovery, and misleading chemical recycling accounting must not count as recycling.
  • Supporting recycling service providers. Funding and reimbursement processes must be accessible to the nonprofit, community-based, and mission-based organizations doing the work, without excessive administrative burdens or costs being shifted onto local communities.
  • Prioritizing waste prevention and protecting communities. The Plan must deliver measurable packaging reduction, expand reuse and refill, and establish meaningful environmental justice and worker protections.

California has an opportunity to set a strong national example for producer responsibility. But success must be measured by less packaging waste, stronger recycling systems, and materials actually recycled, not simply what gets collected or reported on paper.

We are urging CalRecycle to require substantial revisions to CAA’s Program Plan before approving it.

Read AMBR’s full comments here.